Review: The Planet Thieves

First in a series
By Dan Krokos
Available now from Starscape (Tor-Forge/Macmillan)
Review copy

I have to thank Cecelia and Charlotte for reigniting my interest in middle grade fiction.  It's led to me finding some real gems.  THE PLANET THIEVES is something I don't think I've encountered in middle grade before - military sci-fi.  The closest I can think of are the later Alien Adventures books by Bruce Coville.  I loved those books, and I enjoyed THE PLANET THIEVES quite a bit.  The genre isn't the only unexpected thing.

THE PLANET THIEVES was darker than I expected.  I was expecting a bit of a madcap adventure based on the cover and tagline ("Two civilizations.  One planet. And a race to see who steals it first!").  But those two civilizations are at war, and neither side has behaved their best.  Dan Krokos does a good job of describing war, and the actions that are acceptable and unacceptable during wartime, in a way that's suitable for children but not didactic.  (There's also a subtle environmental moral, since both races want a new planet after using their own up.)

Mason Stark is a thirteen-year-old cadet on a diplomatic mission.  He and seventeen other cadets are just supposed to be along for the ride, but when their ship is attacked by the Tremist, the crew is killed or taken hostage.  The cadets have to take charge and Mason become acting captain almost by accident.  His two greatest allies are Tom, a former rival who likes to play by the rules, and Merrin, his best friend who he has a bit of a crush on.

THE PLANET THIEVES weakest aspect is that it's rather boy heavy.  Tom's mother and Mason's older sister are both competent, in-charge women who get sidelined early in the novel.  Willa is the only named female cadet aside from Merrin, and she only plays a part for a split second - fake crying to act as bait.  Several of the male cadets get to take turns as leader.  Merrin, meanwhile,  has to be rescued at least twice.  Tom and Mason at least trade off rescuing each other.  When Merrin does get a chance to save Mason, it's Tom who saves him instead.  In the end, Merrin only gets to keep her agency by the skin of her teeth.  She's not weak.  But she is relegated to the damsel-in-distress and love interest roles despite the fact we're told she's a fierce fighter and good with a computer.

The strongest aspect is the plot.  THE PLANET THIEVES is fast and furious, keeping Mason constantly on the move.  They're doing anything they can think of to save the day, but what the day needs saving from keeps changing.  I also liked that Mason rarely comes out ahead.  He and his allies are clever, but they're thirteen and still training.  They lose in physical contests against adults.  They're out thought by high-ranking officers.  But they keep trying, because they want to do what's right and Mason has the courage and charisma to keep them coordinated and motivated.

THE PLANET THIEVES is a terrific choice for sci-fi fans looking for culture clashes and unexpected revelations.  (I'm definitely giving the nod to Doctor Who fans.)  It ends with quite the hook for the sequel, and I know I'll be back for more.  Be sure to read my interview with Dan Krokos.

Interview with Dan Krokos

Dan Krokos is the author of the False Memory series (FALSE MEMORY, FALSE SIGHT) and THE PLANET THIEVES, the first in a middle grade series.  Released May 21, THE PLANET THIEVES is the story of a Mason Stark and his fellow cadets aboard the Egypt, forced to take control of the spaceship when the crew is captured.

Dan's official bio notes that "[h]e enjoys watching TV, playing MMORPGs, and drinking coffee."

--

1.  What was the biggest difference between writing for a young adult audience and writing for a middle grade audience? 

I think they’re very similar, but the biggest difference is probably the way the story unfolds. For YA, I’ve found most of the books are very personal, with the protagonist changing over the course of the story. It’s very internalized. For middle grade, I think there is more emphasis on the adventure. Also most YA have a very pronounced romance aspect. Middle grade might have a little something (PLANET THIEVES does), but nothing like YA.

2.  I don't think I've ever read middle grade military sci-fi before. What were some of your inspirations?

Star Trek is the obvious inspiration, but for the military aspect, I can probably thank Battlestar Galactica. In that show, everyone is on one ship for most of the series, and the ranks really come into play. Not everyone is on equal footing. I found that a lot of fun to play around with. The cadets start out at the lowest level possible, so it’s cool to see them rise.

3. If you ever encountered an alien race, what do you think would be the best case scenario? 

That we wouldn’t attack them out of fear, and that they wouldn’t attack us. It would be great if they really came in peace, but I don’t trust humans. We’d go nuts. Religions would think this was some kind of sign. I don’t think a best case scenario is really possible, but it would be great if we could somehow learn from each other. They could teach us the science of clean energy, and we could give them burritos!

4. What is the coolest thing that's happened to you as a result of becoming a published author? 

Going to festivals and meeting readers face to face is beyond cool. Visiting studio lots is super cool. Hanging out with other writers I look up to is the coolest.

5. What books are you currently reading? 

N0S4A2 by Joe Hill. RUNNER by Patrick Lee. THE LOST PLANET by Rachel Searles.