September 28, 2012

Review: Audition & Subtraction

Book Cover By Amy Fellner Dominy
Available now from Walker (Bloomsbury)
Review copy

Confession time!  I thought AUDITION & SUBTRACTION was a young adult novel before I started reading it.  I know, I know, the cartoon cover should've given it away, but I didn't.  I was kind of disappointed because I wanted to read about high school band.  (Not that I don't have fond memories of middle school band, too.  I'm just hostile to surprise.)

Tatum is a second clarinet in the Dakota Middle School band, but she still has a chance of being one of three clarinets from the school that earns a spot in the District Honor Band.  But there's a new student in town - and he plays the clarinet too.  To make it worse, he starts dating Lori, Tatum's duet partner for the auditions.  She doesn't have a chance if her secret weapon is distracted by the competition.  And it isn't just about District Honor Band - Tatum may have a shot at making the Wind Ensemble as a freshman if she impresses the high school director at her audition.

(Okay, that last bit really bugged me throughout the book.  There are about seven clarinets in the middle school band.  First off, that indicates there should be enough students that the high school needs at least three bands, not just a Wind Ensemble and Concert Band.  Now, a high school Wind Ensemble should have no more than six clarinets - two per part.  There are three clarinets who are better than Tatum in the middle school.  That means there would have to be less than three upperclassmen better than the freshmen for Tatum to make the band.  That's highly unlikely.  Band geekery over!)

AUDITION & SUBTRACTION is both about friendship and believing in your own abilities.  Lori acts like a bad friend during the novel, but part of her attitude was encouraged by Tatum's lack of belief in herself.  Meanwhile, stand buddy Aaron is clearly way into Tatum but she can't see it because she's too busy obsessing over Lori and Michael.  But perhaps he needs to be more direct about his feelings.  Tatum's life is also complicated by her parents' separation.

I think current, past, and prospective band geeks will enjoy AUDITION & SUBTRACTION.  It's a cute, fun read.  I think I would've preferred it as a YA novel, but that's probably just me being cranky.

6 comments:

  1. *hostile to surprise* lol

    I wasn't really sure if this was a YA or MG book, myself. Good, honest review!! <3

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, I don't want to review a book like an orange instead of an apple. But I want to be honest about it because it does affect your reading experience when you expect something else.

      Delete
  2. Well you may have been disappointed by the target age group, but you've certainly a lot of knowledge of context that is very interesting to read! I suppose getting things completely right isn't seen as so important to middle grade books, but I can understand it being a drawback nonetheless, and I can see why you say it might've made a better YA. Relationships in middle grade aren't going to pack enough punch, so to speak.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, I think MG is great for friendship stories, but I have a harder time getting into the romantic storylines. Maybe because I *wasn't* into dating at that age.

      Delete
  3. Glad you liked it and the friendships regardless of the issues.
    Brandi from Blkosiner’s Book Blog

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for commenting! To reduce spam I moderate all posts older than 14 days.

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...