First, I would like to recognize the victims and survivors of the Aurora, CO shooting as well as the families. They are in our thoughts.
I planned what I wanted to say about The Dark Knight Rises almost as soon as I finished watching it, but my opinion still feels changeable. I've been wavering back and forth on several elements since watching it. So here are some short snippets of my thoughts.
Bane: Like! Gail Simone's Secret Six emphasized Bane's talents at strategy as well as brute strength, and I liked that the movie emphasized his ability to plan. It's a nice contrast from the Joker. In close-ups, Tom Hardy wasn't quite up to acting with his eyes alone, but he was terrific at delivering a convincing brutal beatdown.
Catwoman: Love! The Anne Hathaway haters can all be quiet now. She was tough and vulnerable, as needed. Truly a woman who can one-up the Batman.
The Soundtrack: Dislike. There's nothing wrong with the sound of Hans Zimmer's theme, but it seemed like the music was constantly blaring at top volume. I found it intrusive at several points during the movie.
Blake: Asi-asi. Look, I like Joseph Gordon-Levitt. I also liked his portrayal of an honest cop in Gotham. He's living proof of how Gotham has changed since the beginning of the Nolan trilogy in Batman Begins. But I hate, hate, hated that they fudged with my favorite character's origin to do it. One or two line changes and I wouldn't have cared. (Those who have seen the movie, feel free to discuss this with me.)
Marion Tate: Like. Marion Cotillard is everywhere these days and I, for one, am not complaining. Comic fans will be happy.
Cinematography: Meh. It was a touch to dark and there weren't as many memorable shots as The Dark Knight. It was perfectly serviceable, but disappointing from a director as visual as Christopher Nolan.
Bruce Wayne: Dire. I do not like Bruce Wayne as a bearded, limping shut-in. The man is a motivated machine and Rachel's death put him out of commission for eight years, to let Wayne Enterprises and his charity lapse again? The endless scenes of Bruce wondering whether he's lost his edge dragged the movie down.
Batman: Awesome.
Overall: I loved The Dark Knight Rises. I loved how it brought the trilogy to a close, drawing on elements from the previous movies and the long history of the comics to make a satisfying film. I thought it was a bit slow in the middle, but the explosive opening and thrilling stretch to the ending make up for it. I thought the casting was wonderful, down to small parts like Burn Gorman as Stryver and Daniel Sunjata as Captain Jones. And of course Nolan found another perfect bit for Cillian Murphy to cameo as Dr. Jonathon Crane. Look, my complains about the movie were small and no, it isn't as good as The Dark Knight, but Nolan made a cohesive, exciting trilogy with an interpretation of Batman relevant to our time. It's a staggering achievement for comic book films. The already announced reboot has a lot to live up to.
I am a big Anne fan so it's probably not surprising that I loved her but I did! Her scenes were definitely my favorite :)
ReplyDeleteI'm not familiar with Blake's origins so I have no complaint on that front but I wish his last scene had been a bit more definitive.
I am fan too, but I think she was good enough even for non-fans.
DeleteBlake isn't in the comics, but he replaces a character who is.
I haven't watched the first two movies in the trilogy, but I'm really curious for this one because of Anne Hathaway. I've always liked her, since she and Hugh Dancy were all kinds of adorable in Ella Enchanted.
ReplyDeleteI've only seen a couple of minutes of Ella Enchanted. I should watch the whole movie since I love the book.
DeleteI'd watch the first two movies first - The Dark Knight Rises very much brings things to a close, so quite a bit of it resolves things that happened in the first two movies.
I'm glad to hear Anne Hathaway did well! Always loved her as an actress and how she tries to tackle different roles and doesn't stay only within one genre.
ReplyDeleteI'm sad to admit, but I never watched the previous two movies. Do you think I should watch the first two before this one?
Definitely watch the first two first. The Dark Knight Rises isn't interested in explaining elements that were already introduced in the previous films.
DeleteSad that the middle wasn't as great, but good to know the beginning and end are action packed and good.
ReplyDeleteThanks for review.
Brandi from Blkosiner’s Book Blog
I've seen people who said they liked the pacing, but I thought it was more similar to Batman Begins than The Dark Knight. Thus, slow middle.
DeleteI agree about the Bruce Wayne vs. Batman in this one...Batman was definitely better. I did really enjoy Miranda Tate and I liked Blake! I'm not a comic book person though, so I'm sure his character could have bugged a lot of people, but it worked for me. LOL
ReplyDelete-Lauren
I liked the character of Blake, but hated that they totally replaced my favorite character instead of maybe merging the two a little.
Delete