October 17, 2013

Review: Smith: The Story of a Pickpocket

Smith By Leon Garfield
Available now from NYR Children's Collection
Review copy

I'll read almost anything from NYRB; they're a terrific publisher.  Not too much of a surprise considering they mostly cherry-pick backlists.  The latest release in their children's collection is SMITH: THE STORY OF A PICKPOCKET, a Carnegie Medal Honor book.  Originally published in 1967, it is set back in the eighteenth century. 

It's a little like Dickens for kids, except unlike A CHRISTMAS CAROL it isn't totally boring.  (I love Dickens, but A CHRISTMAS CAROL is a total slog.)  Smith is young, dirty, and stealing to survive.  He lives with his two sisters, who make money sewing hanged men's clothing into new suits.  Given that they live in a poor area, they're often sewing the clothes of old friends.  Then, one day, Smith picks a man's pocket.  Shortly after, he witnesses the man being murdered for his possessions.  Smith has a document that two thugs want, and one big problem.  He can't read.  He has something worth something, finally, but he doesn't know what it is.

SMITH is a charming novel where goodness is rewarded and evil punished, but it takes a lot of work and effort to reach the happy ending.  Smith's life is rough, and there is no magical way to make it better.  He runs into a kindly, blind magistrate and his daughter who are a great help, but they cannot save Smith alone.  Plus, Smith isn't blameless.  He lies, and steals, and he has to learn empathy if he's going to be the good guy.

Leon Garfield does an excellent job at evoking the period.  Well enough that SMITH is probably best saved for children who can have conversations about capital punishment, because there is a lot of execution going on.  Other conversations about the period would probably be less fraught.  And hey, this is a book where literacy is a matter of life and death.  That's pretty cool.

I enjoyed SMITH quite a bit, and think this is one of those children's books that has strong appeal for adults.  C'mon, it's about a thief who is friends with a highwayman and there are relentless henchman!  It's a pulpy adventure, told in classic style.  I may have to look up some of the rest of Garfield's extensive backlist.


  1. Wow, this sounds like a fantastic story, and I'm glad to hear it has crossover appeal. I always feel a little silly reading middle grade books, but it looks like I won't have to in this case. Thanks for introducing me to this one!

  2. I was spooked off Leon Garfield when I was eight by reading one of his darkest books...I went back to it a few times to try again (deperate for books as I was), but it always distressed me too much too finish. But I agree that NYRB has republished lots of great stuff!

    1. Yeah, this one is definitely dark for a children's book - lots of hangings and such. I'm not sure I could imagine darker!

  3. It was Black Jack, btw--"An atmospheric and chilling thriller set in 19th century London. Bartholomew Dorking finds himself inexplicably tied to the murdering villain Black Jack, who should have hung from the gallows - but who has now, it seems, come back from the dead!" Not a good choice for little me.


Thanks for commenting! To reduce spam I moderate all posts older than 14 days.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...